Print Print RSS

The Mammogram Controversy

So Much for Evidence-Based Medicine

John B. McKinlay

“No good deed goes unpunished” is a dictum that applies to the ongoing controversy surrounding recommendations of the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force (USPSTF), an independent group of 16 private sector clinicians and scientists appointed by the federal Department of Health and Human Services (DHHS), which rigorously assesses ever changing evidence on medical care, and makes recommendations based on explicit criteria. Their recommendations, which do not apply to a small group at high risk for breast cancer, now suggest women in their 40s should stop routinely having annual ammograms, that women aged 50-74 should have them less frequently (every two years rather than every year) and that breast self-examinations produce no significant medical benefit. Just 7 years earlier (2002) the same group, but with different members looking at earlier evidence, recommended annual mammograms for women starting at age 40. The task force also reversed its previous guidance that encouraged doctors to teach women how to do breast self-exams.

Download the Article
PDF (142KB)






Marceau, L., McKinlay, J. B., Shackelton, R., & Link, C. (Epub ahead of print). The relative contribution of patient, provider and organizational influences to the appropriate diagnosis and management of diabetes mellitus. Journal of Evaluation in Clinical Practice.

Siegrist, J., Shackelton, R., Link, C., Marceau, L., von dem Knesebeck, O., McKinlay, J. (2010). Work stress of primary care physicians in the US, UK and German health care system. Social Science and Medicine, 71(2), 298-304.

Von dem Knesebeck, O., Bonte, M., Siegrist, J., Marceau, L., Link, C., & McKinlay, J. (2010). Diagnosis and therapy of depression in the elderly--influence of patient and physician characteristics. Psychother Psychosom Med Psychol, 60(3-4), 98-103.

Konrad, T. R., Link, C. L., Shackelton, R. J., Marceau, L. D., von dem Knesebeck, O., Siegrist, J., et al. (2010). It's about time: Physicians' perceptions of time constraints in primary care medical practice in three national healthcare systems. Medical Care, 48(2), 95-100.

Von dem Knesebeck, O., Gerstenberger, E., Link, C., Marceau, L., Roland, M., Campbell, S., et al. (2010). Differences in the diagnosis and management of type 2 diabetes in 3 countries (US, UK, and Germany): Results from a factorial experiment. Medical Care, 48(4), 321-326.

Grant, R. W., Lutfey, K. E., Gerstenberger, E., Link, C. L., Marceau, L. D., & McKinlay, J. B. (2009). The decision to intensify therapy in patients with type 2 diabetes: results from an experiment using a clinical case vignette. The Journal of the American Board of Family Medicine, 22(5), 513-520.

Maserejian, N. N., Lutfey, K. E., & McKinlay, J. B. (2009). Do physicians attend to base rates? Prevalence data and statistical discrimination in the diagnosis of coronary heart disease. Health Services Research, 44(6), 1933-1949.

Shackelton, R. J., Marceau, L. D., Link, C. L., & McKinlay, J. B. (2009). The intended and unintended consequences of clinical guidelines. Journal of Evaluation in Clinical Practice, 15(6), 1035-1042.

Shackelton, R., Link, C., Marceau, L., & McKinlay, J. (2009). Does the culture of a medical practice affect the clinical management of diabetes by primary care providers? Journal of Health Services Research and Policy, 14(2), 96-103.

Jackson, C.B., Botelho, E.M., Welch, L.C., Joseph J., & Tennstedt, S.L. (2012). Talking With Others About Stigmatized Health Conditions: Implications for Managing Symptoms. Qualitative Health Research, Epub ahead of print.

Link, C.L., Stern, T.A., Piccolo, R.S., Marceau, L.D., Arber, S., Adams, A., Siegrist, J., von dem Knesebeck, O., McKinlay, J.B. (2011). Diagnosis and Management of Depression in 3 Countries: Results From a Clinical Vignette Factorial Experiment. The Primary Care Companion for CNS Disorders, 13(5), e1-e7.

Lutfey, K.E., Campbell, S.M., Marceau, L.D., Roland, M.O., McKinlay, J.B. (2012). Influences of organizational features of healthcare settings on clinical decision making: Qualitative results from a cross-national factorial experiment. Health, 16(1), 40-56.

Marceau L, McKinlay J, Shackelton, R, Link C. (2011). The relative contribution of patient, provider and organizational influences to the appropriate diagnosis and management of diabetes mellitus. Journal of Evaluation in Clinical Practice, 17(6),1122-8.

McKinlay, J.B., Marceau, L.D., Piccolo, R.J. (2012). Do doctors contribute to the social patterning of disease? The case of race/ethnic disparities in diabetes mellitus. Medical Care Research and Review, 69(2),176-93.

McKinlay J.B., & Marceau, L.D. (2011). New wine in an old bottle: does alienation provide an explanation of the origins of physician discontent? International Journal of Health Services, 41(2), 301-35.

Oka, M., Link, C.L., Kawachi, I. (2011). Disparities in the prevalence of obesity in Boston: results from the Boston Area Community Health (BACH) survey. Public Health Reports, 126(5), 700-7.

Shackelton-Piccolo, R., McKinlay, J.B., Marceau, L.D., Goroll, A.H., Link, C.L. (2011). Differences between internists and family practitioners in the diagnosis and management of the same patient with coronary heart disease. Medical Care Research and Review, 68(6), 650-66.

Welch, L.C., Lutfey, K.E., Gerstenberger, E., Grace, M. (2012). Gendered uncertainty and variation in physicians' decisions for coronary heart disease: the double-edged sword of "atypical symptoms". Journal of Health and Social Behavior, 53(3), 313-28.

Welch, L.C., Botelho, E.M., Joseph, J.J., Tennstedt, S.L. (2012). A qualitative inquiry of patient-reported outcomes: the case of lower urinary tract symptoms. Nursing Research, 61(4), 283-90.

Welch, L.C., Botelho, E.M., Tennstedt, S.L. (2011). Race and ethnic differences in health beliefs about lower urinary tract symptoms. Nursing Research, 60(3), 165-72.

McKinlay, J.B. & Marceau, L.D. (2012). From cottage industry to a dominant mode of primary care: stages in the diffusion of a health care innovation (retail clinics). Social Science & Medicine, 75(6), 1134-41.

Heretic's Corner
10/4/2011 - Posted by NERI Upstream
For example, how useful is it to encourage households in poverty (experiencing food insecurity) to consume more costly “healthful” diets (lean meats, whole grains and fresh vegetables and fruit). The examples are endless............